Last week I observed quite a few encounters with authors online, encounters that ranged from mildly bothersome to seriously off-putting. This prompted me to ask pose the question of whether author behavior matters to you, as a reader, when it comes to buying/borrowing books. I've noticed, more and more, that author behavior online does influence my reading habits...and I really wish it didn't.
Thinking back to my earliest reading experiences, I can't say that I was even aware of authors as anything more than names on the cover on my books. The only time those names were important was if I really loved a book, and I wanted more of the same. My reading at that time was motivated mostly by random fancy, and I would read anything with an intriguing cover or title. Anything. I felt no connection to the authors, and I didn't care because I had such a strong connection to the books.
Now, it's difficult to say whether my paradigm shift was due to growing up, or the evolution of the internet and the online reading community--probably some combination of the two. In any case, these days I'm more conscious of the author responsible for every book I read--aware of the style, personality, and work that they put into those books. But more to the point, I'm aware of authors as brand names. Many authors promote themselves and their books online with great enthusiasm. Just take a look at Gail Carriger's website. Spend ten minutes browsing it and you'll have a pretty good idea of what her work is like, and a pretty good idea of whether you would like to try one of her books.
So, the internet has made me more aware of authors as artists, and of authors as brand names. And from a book selling perspective (the author's) or a book buying perspective (mine), this is all a good thing. They get to sell their product the way they want to, I get to buy things I like, everyone is happy. Where this all falls apart for me is when I become too aware of authors as people. And actually, even that is fine about 90% of the time--I don't really mind if an author posts on his/her blog about beloved pets or shoe shopping or favorite flavors of cheese. The problem is this: some people are jerks. And even non-jerks have bad days when they behave badly.
Hypothetically, let's say that an author has said or done something online that you find appalling. Can you ignore it enough to still buy (or borrow) and enjoy his/her book? I can't, and that kind of saddens me. Once that name is stuck it my mind as "That one author that went ballistic on goodreads/amazon because of bad reviews" I literally cannot bring myself to buy that book. Who knows, I might be missing out on something I'd really enjoy, all because the author chose to act like a dick one time. Am I the only one with this problem?
The bottom line is, while I love the connectivity of the online reading community, part of me longs for that time when authors seemed like the anonymous magicians behind the awesome experience of books. Maybe someday soon I'll mature a little more as a reader and be able to read books by misbehaving authors, without bias or preconceived notions. Or maybe not. Maybe they really don't deserve my time and money.
How has author behavior influenced you? Have you ever been driven to read a book because of an author's awesome online presence? Or driven away by off-putting behavior? Have you found a way to ignore all of it altogether? Share your thoughts in the comments! Happy Monday, everyone!
I think once you have a poor experience with someone, whether it is online or through a personal interaction, it is very difficult to separate that from their work. Authors with an online presence can either use it to bond with their audience or end up driving away potential readers.
ReplyDeleteThat's exactly right. I've seen authors with AMAZING online presences that draw fans in and keep them reading for a long time. It seems like it's a lot of work for them, though.
DeleteI think I know of the specific incident you are referring to and like you, I wish it didn't colour my opinion of their books. Recently, I made a sort of connection with a few authors I love and it's somehow made the task of reading their books a bit awkward. Before when I'd read a book, I didn't know who wrote it and that was fine with me. Now I know I can get in touch with people so easily and it's kinda taken the magic out of it.
ReplyDeleteMildly bothersome=Maggie Steifvater tells us that online reviews don't matter. That just...I refuse to even comment on that anymore. But at least she wasn't horribly disrespectful.
DeleteSeriously off-putting=The flame outs on reviews on goodreads. I won't bother linking to them because I'm not interested in ruining those authors for anyone else(if there's anyone left that hasn't seen them) There were less recent ones on amazon that still stick in my head too.
And yeah, even being friends with an author carries a level of awkwardness to it. Hopefully you can put it out of your mind enough to read as you always do, but it's hard!
I think one of the advantages to being a time-crunched blogger is that I don't spent a lot of time socializing online. I pop onto twitter for a few minutes here and there, and of course am visiting blogs and commenting, but that's about it, so I avoid a lot of the drama.
ReplyDeleteWill negative behavior by an another cause me to avoid reading a book? Possibly. It will definitely make me cautious about reviewing it. (I've got a review going live tomorrow of a book I didn't like, and I'm a little nervous because I've seen some snark from the author. Still...it's a copy received via Netgalley and I have to review it, so hopefully, all goes well.)
You are so very lucky, and very smart, to avoid the drama. There are so many comments and posts I wish I could un-see!
DeleteAs for writing bad reviews, don't worry about it. Be respectful, be honest, and don't make personal attacks on the author. You are reviewing THE BOOK, not the person who wrote it. If you do all of that, and the author or anyone else decides to attack you, they are the ones that will come out looking like idiots. But honestly, from what I've seen those attacks are comparatively rare.
great post! I've read several posts about bad reviews and author's reactions.
ReplyDeletebtw thanks for commenting on my review of Lover Eternal. Just want to say that I sympathized with Mary. I think it's because I've read the book before that it bothered me a little, but I think Ward did a great job with Mary's character.
Ning @ Reading by Kindle Fire
You're very welcome! I always think it's interesting to see other reader's perspective's on characters. I've read that book loads of times and her story always (always!) breaks my heart, but I think I'm a little more sensitive to it than most.
Delete(To anyone wondering what we're talking about, Ning wrote a very nice review of Lover Eternal HERE)