Showing posts with label 1 star book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1 star book. Show all posts

Friday, May 4, 2012

On Pencils: A Review of Daphne and the Mysterious Girls Secret Bathroom Society

Alright people. Brace yourselves for a little ranting.

In the interest of absolute, full disclosure, I must admit that I don't think that I'm at all the target audience of this book. The characters are younger teens (14 I think?) and perhaps on the immature side of that. So a lot of their behavior was baffling and irritating to my 20 something mind. Apparently I'm growing out of touch. Who knew? I really should have figured this out before agreeing to read and review it.

That said, not every problem with this book can be blamed on the age gap, and I'll get to my issues momentarily. First, the plot summary. Daphne find out that magic is real. Only girls are supposed to have it, and they access it by making motions specific to each of them (nose twitching, foot tapping, etc.) and saying some funny words. Daphne's enemy at school, Vi, is also a witch. As are most of the girls. In a series of random info-dumps, we learn that men used to have power as wizards, but then all wizards were whipped out, and should they pop up again we all have to be very afraid of them. Oh, and Daphne has a crush on a boy named Kyle. Guess what happens next?

Positive Comments

The premise is undeniably humorous. I did laugh out loud several times.

Daphne has a hamster named Mr. Nibbles, and I'm very fond of hamsters.

Critical Comments

This book made me hate words. Like "Ticonderoga" and "Inertia". I utterly despise the term "knockers" now. Shield's writing style is clumsy, with awkward syntax and the repeated use of words that simply should not be repeated.

The world building is vague and flimsy. Hey, there's magic! You can do anything with it! You can teleport and freeze people and shapeshift to look like other people and...What are the rules? What are the inherent restrictions in this "magic"? Why isn't anyone using it to cure cancer or solve world hunger? Why the gender bias? None of this makes any sense! On top of this, all attempts at world building involve info-dumping via a red book with magic invisible writing...

And I think every girl is supposed to have her own red book, but early in the story, one girl's book is stolen. Why steal something like that? And when an adult witch sees the drama over the stolen book, she let's the thief keep it, binding it to her magically. Wha? Huh? Why...

The adult behavior is perhaps more baffling than the children's. They basically say "Oh, hey, you all have magic. You know what you should do? Form a club to govern you. Make your own damn decisions. We adults have better things to do, and you can't be in our coven anymore!" Because if there's one thing fourteen year old girls are good at, it's coming together as a group to make fair and rational decisions. And you know, it's not like they have some kind of real power to affect the world in potentially devastating ways--oh wait, they do!

The dialogue is bad. Go ahead, say "Knockers" one more time. It just gets funnier and funnier.

The character interactions are bad. There's one girl who has to grab her chest in order to cast a spell, because that's her witch "motion", and they take great pains to point it out repeatedly. Oh, and at one point a girls slaps Daphne's butt, and Daphne tries to slap her back. Real nice.

The characters are unlikeable. Daphne is a magic idiot savant, because, you know, she's the main character. I saw no emotion and no development in her that remotely endeared her to me.

Recommendation

If you want something that's "So bad it's hilarious" this might be a good pick. Or, I might recommend this to very young or inexperienced readers. But in reality, no, I don't suggest reading this. 1 star.

Buy from Amazon: Daphne and The Mysterious Girls Secret Bathroom Society

Friday, February 10, 2012

On Carriers: A Review of Carrier of the Mark by Leigh Fallon

I'm going to be honest right from the start: I hate this book. Quite a bit. And while I don't usually write ranting reviews, sometimes one is called for...I'm trying not to go over board. But I really hate this book.

First off, whats the plot? Bella Megan is a teenage girl who lives with her single father, Charlie Caleb. The two have just moved to Forks Kinsale. Megan makes instant, close friendships on her first day of school, despite having a fairly bland personality. More importantly, she finds herself helplessly drawn to Edward Adam, a mysterious boy from a mysterious family. There are a lot of rumors surrounding Adam's family, rumors that suggest he's a vampire werewolf magic user. Adam seems to have influence over water. His sister, Alice Aine has earth powers and can sense the future, but not at any point where it becomes useful. Their older brother, Rian, mostly broods and smolders. Anyway, it seems that Megan is their missing link--the final member in their magic team, which is destined to complete the alignment and bring balance to...something. But first, Megan has to accept her power, and a destiny that might prevent her from being with Adam romantically.

Positive Comments:

The use of magic approached interesting on one or two occasions. And I like that this book was set in Ireland. And...the cover is nice.

Critical Comments:

In case I didn't make it clear above, this book has very strong parallels to Twilight. And, remember, I skimmed through Twilight only once a few years ago, and I've seen the movie twice, so I'm far from an expert, but even I could not stop spotting the similarities. This strikes me as lazy and unoriginal. Though, I guess if you are a big Twilight fan this would probably be a plus for you.

Megan is unlikeable. She's the blank slate, average girl character that author's write because they want every reader to be able to relate to her directly. I don't like that trope, because I think it makes the characters boring. But that's not even the worst of it. As described above, Megan has powers that she needs to evoke, an action that by all accounts would be good for the whole world. The catch is, if she evokes them, she might not get to be with Adam romantically. She decides she doesn't want her powers, because she can't bear not being with Adam. She's willing to sacrifice the power that is hers by right, thereby potentially endangering or screwing over the world, all so that she can keep her boyfriend. Our heroine, ladies and gentlemen!

Now, I could have gotten in Megan's corner about the whole "Love is more important than anything" idea, if I actually believed for one second that Adam and Megan were in love. But I just didn't buy it. It's insta-love, which is irritating enough by itself. There's no relationship development. There's no real "meet cute" or "getting to know each other" phase. There's no chemistry. The author tells us they're in love, but fails utterly at actually showing us.

This brings me to my final complaint, which is all of the telling and info-dumping that goes on in this book. The exposition goes on and on. The action is sparse and uncreative. The author feeds us all of the world building in character dialogue, instead of finding an exciting way of showing us the world. It's very bland and very boring.

Recommendation:

I'd recommend this book to those who really love Twilight and want more of the same, and those who like the insta-love trope. Personally, I despised this book. 1 star.

Buy Carrier of the Mark from Amazon

Monday, June 20, 2011

Vampire. Warrior. Legend. Loser.

The best way that I can explain Ascension by Caris Roane is this: Imagine that J.R. Ward's Black Dagger Brotherhood books and Nalini Singh's Guild Hunter books had a baby, and that baby grew up into a troubled teenager. That's this book. But troubled teens aren't irredeemable, right? Sure, it's going to take some discipline on the part of the editor and a lot of patience on the part of the reader, but it could still turn out alright. At least, that's what I told myself as I powered through the first two thirds of this book. In the end though, it's just a bad seed, and not really one I cared to stick with.

Here is my list of issues with this book:

1. This is a fated mates book. Hero and heroine are destined to be together because the author says so. Their sexual chemistry is instantaneous and irrationally overblown. The initial stages of getting to know one another involve smelling each other, gazing longingly into each others eyes, and dreaming of each other. I'm not against fated mates as a rule, but there is a right and a wrong way to do it. The wrong way is taking away all of your character's choices and forcing them on one another, and using the mate bond as a stand in (or even total replacement) for growing affection. For the most part this book does it the wrong way.

2. The groups of hulk-like warrior men battling evil? It's been done before. Many times. And done better than this. This book is just generally unoriginal, kind of like fan fiction where all the names have been changed.

3. Roane's writing style is horrible. Typos, awkward wording, abrupt and frequent shifts in POV, one and two word sentences, needless repetition. The dialogue is the worst, with lots of phony sounding tough talk. One glaring example was when in detailing a character's thoughts Roane used "helluvan" instead of "hell of an". Now, I was willing to chalk up a lot of these issues to Roane being a new author, but upon flipping to her bio I saw that she has published many books under the name Valerie King. I couldn't believe that an experienced author would write like this.


4. Silly half baked world building. For one thing, the heroine is given an incomprehensible number of super powers. And the hero and his band of brothers are vampires...with wings. I started calling them wampires. There are good wampires and bad wampires, and the bad ones are blue for some reason. There are multiple dimensions including Mortal Earth and Earth Two. So there are all kinds of rules about where the wampires can fight and how they can fight. And there's vocabulary to learn as well. My favorite was the power of making objects disappear and appear, which is called "folding". Whenever it set "folding his sword into his hand" I could not stop picturing him folding a sword in half. Bottom line, all of the concepts are B-movie quality at best.

5. And finally, the sequel baiting. You want to buy the next book, right? That's going to be Marcus' story. He sounds cool right? Buy his book. Buy it! Ugh. I just want to enjoy the novel I'm reading and get a complete story without having to spend another $8 to complete the tale.

What can I say that's positive? When the heroine, Alison, is first introduced I thought she might be interesting. She has a lot of emotional issues and identity issues that I wanted to see her work through. But when it became clear that her powers and her relationship with Kerrick were going to be her new identity I lost interest in her. Kerrick bored me with his angst, self pity, and stubbornness. He did sound physically attractive though. Many of the secondary characters, like Endelle the military leader, were intriguing. This was ruined the second they spoke a word of dialogue.

So if you really like fated mates, haven't had your fill of vampire gang wars, and don't mind sloppy writing, go ahead and try this book. 1 star.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...